Amy and TJ Misrepresenting Relationship Timeline?

This week former Good Morning America co-hosts TJ Holmes and Amy Robach launched their podcast claiming it was a misconception that either of them cheated on their spouses to be together [click here if you missed that]. 

Not so fast...

From The Daily Mail

They have said they never cheated on their spouses, but sources close to TJ Holmes and Amy Robach's heartbroken exes say the pair were romantic at least five months before their affair was exposed by DailyMail.com.

And now, in an amazing turn of events, those exes – Andrew Shue and Marliee Fiebig – have had the last laugh as they've found love again- with each other.

The former Good Morning America 3 anchors were outed as a couple a year ago and were fired by ABC six weeks after their affair was revealed.

Now the pair are attempting to rewrite history – saying on their new iHeartRadio podcast that they had already split from Andrew, 56, and Marilee, 45, before they got together.

But DailyMail.com can reveal that Holmes, 46, and Robach, 50, were both still living with their spouses when their affair began – and that they went to great lengths to conceal their involvement, even standing 20ft apart before getting picked up in the same car in a bid to cover their tracks.

That all went wrong when DailyMail.com published exclusive photos showing the pair cuddling up in a Big Apple bar, holding hands in an Uber and shacking up in an upstate New York cottage for a romantic weekend two weeks before Thanksgiving last year.

An insider said: 'This has been going on for far longer than they're letting on – everyone was talking about how close they were in London [for the Queen's Diamond Jubilee] last year.

'That was in June - but they didn't break up with Andrew and Marilee until August.'

Both insisted their divorces were 'well underway' before their affair was exposed – but didn't mention their attempts to hide their relationship nor the fact that no divorce papers had been filed when their romance was revealed.

As DailyMail.com previously reported, the pair had become close friends due to their shared love of running and the Great Outdoors.

Their friendship ultimately grew so intimate, the duo would socialize as a foursome with their respective spouses.

An insider told DailyMail.com: 'Everyone knows that Amy and T.J. have been close friends for a long time now, running together and even socializing as a foursome with each other's spouses.'

Photographs posted on 50-year-old Robach's Instagram in March 2022 show Holmes with his arm casually draped on her now ex-husband Shue's shoulder, with both men apparently firmly part of Robach's 'half marathon posse.'

But all that changed after the couple traveled to London to front the coverage of the late Queen's Diamond Jubilee.

Insiders said Holmes and Robach's relationship evolved in June, if not before, 'when they were in London together filming the Queen's Diamond Jubilee for ABC and staff were buzzing about the intimacy between them.'

The couple and their exes went their separate ways in August but Holmes and Robach still went to great lengths to conceal their blossoming romance – with Robach even disabling comments on her Instagram when followers started commenting on her missing wedding ring.

In a bizarre twist, sources told Page Six that Shue and Fiebig are now dating themselves after bonding over the experience of being cheated on.